Savoring the best pies on Maui is a delightful experience that combines tropical flavors with a touch of luxury. Whether you’re diving into a slice of key lime pie after a morning swim with sea turtles or indulging in rich chocolate cream pie, Maui’s pie scene offers something for everyone. From charming local bakeries to bustling eateries, here’s a guide to the best pies on Maui, as ranked by editors of HAWAI’I Magazine in their March/April “Best of the Best” edition. When your sweet craving strikes, these spots are sure to deliver.
1. Maui Pie
Nestled in a Kihei strip mall, Maui Pie may not look impressive from the outside, but their pies are a local treasure. These handcrafted pies are the epitome of the best pies on Maui. Enjoy a variety of flavors like lilikoi (passion fruit), mango strawberry, or the classic banana cream pie. If you plan to sample them all, bring some family and friends to help. For an exceptional pie experience, visit Maui Pie at 1280 South Kihei Rd., Kihei, Maui, or check out their website at mauipie.com.
2. Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop
A must-visit for pie enthusiasts, Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop is renowned for its incredible selection of the best pies on Maui. From Olowalu lime to macadamia-nut chocolate, each pie is crafted with fresh Maui ingredients. Even though the café is often busy, the delicious pies are well worth the wait. Located at Olowalu Village Rd., Olowalu, Maui, Leoda’s offers both sweet and savory options. Learn more at leodas.com.
3. Sugar Beach Bake Shop
For an early start to your pie adventure, head to Sugar Beach Bake Shop in North Kihei. Known for its delectable key lime and chocolate cream pies, Sugar Beach Bake Shop serves up some of the best pies on Maui. Open at 6am, it’s the perfect place to enjoy a morning treat made from locally grown ingredients. Visit them at 61 South Kihei Rd., Kihei, Maui, or find them online at sugarbeachbikeshop.com.
4. Monkeypod Kitchen
While Monkeypod Kitchen in Wailea is celebrated for its dinners and cocktails, don’t miss out on their dessert menu. Featuring rich strawberry and coconut cream pies, this spot is a hidden gem among the best pies on Maui. The fresh, locally sourced strawberries and crumbly crusts are made right on the island. Find Monkeypod Kitchen at Ten Wailea Gateway Place, Wailea, Maui, or visit monkeypodkitchen.com for more information.
5. Pono Pies
For a healthier twist, Pono Pies offers a unique take on the best pies on Maui. Made from breadfruit (ulu) and using locally grown ingredients, these pies are free from sugar, gluten, dairy, and eggs. Popular flavors include Maui coffee and chocolate, molokai sweet potato, and haupia (coconut cream pudding). Available at local stores like Mana Foods and Fork and Salad in Kahului, Pono Pies is a must-try for a different pie experience. Check out their website at ponopies.com for more details.
When exploring the best pies on Maui, these locations promise a sweet and memorable experience. Whether you’re craving a classic or something a bit different, Maui’s pie scene has you covered. Enjoy your pie adventure on the Valley Isle!